| 
              
                |  |  
                |  |  
                | 
 |  
                
                  |  |  |  
                  | 
 |  
                
                  |  |  |  
                  
                  
                 
                  | Value  |  
                  |  |  
                  | 
                    We  paid a few quid under £90 for 2 starters, 2 mains, a shared pudding, an  optional tenner service charge, and a bottle of San Pel sparkling water, to  give those beaten-up livers a bit of a break as much as Dry Jan never sees the  light of day around here.  But all in  all, the value was balanced with the quality.  Wine  markups were fine, with the entry bottle (Villa Rossi Sangiovese del Rubicone)  weighing in at a respectably restrained £24.95, which accounted for a 3x markup  on the RRP, which was again perfectly acceptable really.  Looking  further down the list; the iconic Antinori Solaia is on there for £375, and  that retails at about £325, so a mere 1.1x markup on such a stellar drop is  astonishing value for money.  I never  drink super spenny wine in restaurants, simply because I begrudge paying a  fortune for the privilege of somebody opening it for me and such wines should  be opened hours before you arrive, but I may treat myself the next time we are  in!  |  
                  |  |  
                  | 
                    £6 for a bottle of San Pel is pushing the  boundaries.  We almost ordered wine on  principle. |  
                  |  |  
                
                  |  |  |  
                  
                  
                 
                  | Food & Drink  |  
                  |  |  
                  | 
                    Garlic Bread with Tomato (£8.5) was the crowd  pleaser that we hoped it would be.  A  well baked crust with a very pleasant texture, topped simply and classically with  bags of fresh tomato and some token slivers of basil.  It’s a dish which can't really fail to go  down well.   Steak Tartare (£15) seems to be a classic dish in  any nation's culinary repertoire.   The Don Giovanni was a solid version, with chunky pieces of hand chopped steak,  dressed really well, carrying the right amount of seasoning and then topped  with strings of potato to add that all important textural element.   Orecchiette  Arrabiata (£16.5) showcased some perfectly al dente pasta, which was clearly  made with love, dressed in a fresh tomato sauce, coming in a hearty portion too.  The stereotypically British/Italian massive  pepper mill added a few flecks of pepper and a smile.   Chicken Parmigiana (£19) was a real favourite of the  table, because let's face it, who doesn’t love some form of fried chicken.  Juicy within, encased in a properly seasoned crispy  fried exterior, with some rocket and a swoosh of sauce to complete things.  This disappeared without much resistance.  |  
                  |  |  
                
                  |  |  |  
                  
                  
                 
                  | 
                    We decided to posh things up and dodge the regular  fries which were suggested for the above, and instead went with a side of Polenta  Chips (£6.50).  It was a good call, and  the nuggets of crispy fried polenta, dressed with grated Parmesan and pesto  mayo, went down a treat.    And then finally onto pudding; a shared Cheesecake  (£9) was a highlight of the evening's plates and was in this case a Sicilian  ricotta variant which came plated with some spiced cherries.    Made  in-house, the base was just the right thickness, with a lovely rich filling in  the right ratio, based to perfection.   Delicious.    |  
                  |  |  
                  | 
                    But,  the Arrabiata lacked chilli punch, and the Parm's crust quickly lost its crisp  after being served.  |  
                  |  |  
                
                  |  |  |  
                  
                  
                 
                  | Overall  |  
                  |  |  
                  | 
                    The  newly launched/latest iteration of Manchester's oldest indie Italian has come  out swinging, and whilst they opened a couple of months ago, we prefer to give  places a bit of time before heading in to do reviews as it's only fair.  But you get the impression that no wait was  needed to be honest. Sure,  it's a new restaurant per se, but the guys feel as if they've been there for a  million years, the menu is confident and accessible, and the drinks offering is  also strong as much as we chose to opt out of the beverages on this occasion  after a heavy month of indulgence. Generally,  it's just a real crowd pleaser and feels right for the market in terms of product  and value, being ideally situated to make the most of footfall from surrounding  theatres and the bustle of upper Oxford St.   The menu contains something for all tastes and budgets and is studded  with all the classics and obligatory dishes, accented with a selection of  elevated options for those who prefer something a bit different from their  usual Carbonara.  It wasn’t difficult to  find something for the whole table, as much as for the purpose of a review  which hopefully resonates with you readers, we opted for the more typical and  popular plates on this visit.   But we  will return to explore further.  And  that's the biggest question when reviewing anywhere; would we go back? We  went in for a solid, tasty meal, set in a lovely dining room with a great  ambiance, and we walked away having receiving exactly that.  So yes, we would indeed return, and will indeed  do just that.  So should you, and there's  a good reason why these guys have been around since 1984. |  
                  |  |  
                
                  | Don Giovanni Reviews |  
                  | Don Giovanni, reopened its doors in November, 2024, marking a new chapter in its 40-years legacy. The restaurant returned with a refreshed look, modern interiors and an exciting menu - all while preserving the timeless traditions that have made it a beloved institution for generations. |  |